ASUS K70IC-X1 Review
This is a laptop I bought for school. With a pricetag of about $700, it isn’t too shabby, assuming you don’t plan to use the DVD Burner.
Processor
This machine is fast. With a Dual core 2.2Ghz processor, this thing can easily run Windows 7 Ultimate with little or no hesitation. However, the motherboard on the system does not support 64bit memory isolation, making it impossible to run 64bit virtual machines inside VMWare, an inconvenience for myself but could be a deal-breaker for others. The processors do sport a two step frequency listing. Low power is at 1.2Ghz and Full power is at 2.2Ghz. Newer intel processors can do many more frequencies based on load. 2MB L2 cache is sufficient for this machine. The heatsync does its job quite well on this laptop, it has a separate cooling device from the video card and the laptop has tons of airflow. There are times when the system can burn your leg from heat exhaust but that can be solved by elevating the rear of the laptop. This system could heat a small room in the winter when being used at full speed.
Memory


The laptop comes stock with 4GB of memory. The sticks are matched Kingston memory modules. The memory is a Dual Channel 400Mhz DDR2. This allows for a full speed of 800Mhz memory. This matches the FSB of the processor and allows for the memory to be able to keep up with the front side bus. This keeps bottlenecks down. The memory is NON-ECC, NON-FBDIMM, This makes performance memory very cheap since DDR2 is the memory in highest production at this time.
Graphics
The graphics card in the laptop is very powerful. With 1GB of dedicated onboard memory it allows for a significant gain since the laptop does not have to share memory with the video card. This video card does have problems running GTA4 as it doesn’t have the internal horsepower needed. The video card also has built in power management that allows it to scale down to 275Mhz Core Clock when running a 2D desktop up to 500Mhz Core Clock when running a 3D application. The video card has it’s own built in fan and heatsync to allow it to cool separately from the processor and the rest of the system. It doesn’t get nearly as hot as the processor but does come on when gaming.
Physical Characteristics
The laptop is rigid and doesn’t feel light or flimsy. The keyboard is responsive and very easy to get used to. It follows the same standard as most IBM keyboards and avoids some of the pitfalls of the Lenovo keyboards. The CD Tray (Also a DVD Burner) has an ejection button that sits out WAY too far. I am usually able to run my hand down the side of the laptop, or able to pick it up and the tray will pop open.
Problems
Oh, don’t get me started here. Since I have owned the laptop I have ran into a few problems.
#1 – Laptop APM doesn’t play well with hard drives. Sometimes the hard drives will attempt to enter a safety mode when they detect a “drop condition”, the motherboard doesn’t like this and instructs the drive to wake-up. This causes an endless cycle of clicking until the laptop is rebooted due to whatever firmware bug exists in the motherboard. BIOS and Hard drive are up to latest manufacturer releases and this error is present in different drives. While this doesn’t appear to do any long term damage to the drive it is a real inconvenience. A simple nudge or bump in the wrong direction can make the drive enter this condition and make the laptop have to be hard rebooted.
#2 – Mouse key clickers wear out very quickly. Whenever you ‘click’ on an item with a mouse you get that actual ‘click’. After about 4 to 6 months my left mouse clicker wore out and makes no sound at all now. There is no snapping resistance like there is with the right mouse clicker.
#3 – DVD Burner. The DVD burner is junk. It cannot properly burn a DVD. The geometry that the burner uses to put data on a disc is very incorrect. I burned a Windows 7 Ultimate backup copy on the laptop and was unable to boot it on the same laptop. I burn the CD on a MAC in the next room and I am able to see the physical differences between the two DVDs. The MAC burned at a higher speed but still produced more pronounced pits indicating a higher burning power. The MAC also used more of the surface area, this indicates that the laptop does not use the correct geometry and does not have the correct power level setting on the DVD drive to properly burn a DVD.
#4 – Case squeeks. At the front of the case on either side of the trackpad there are large open areas to rest the wrists. When enough pressure is placed on the edges the laptop creeks as the plastic bends and rubs against the top and the bottom. This can get quite annoying when using the laptop at a desk.
#5 – HDMI Placement. HDMI Placement is on the back of the laptop. the ONLY connector on the back of the laptop. With plenty of room along the sides still available I am not sure why the manufacturer chose to put the HDMI on the rear of the laptop.
Conclusion
The laptop is a good piece of equipment overall but does need some engineering changes to be a real work of art. Moving the HDMI sensor, fixing the case squeeks, a different DVD burner (with a low profile or recessed ejection button) and a drive chipset that plays nicely with modern drives.
TL;DR – I would not recommend this laptop to anyone as it seems that it wears out very quickly and I’m sure soon the keyboard will begin to malfunction.
